9 Places You Absolutely Have To Eat In New York City

IMG_8705

Before I dive right in and serve up some of the sweetest food porn your eyes have probably laid eyes on today, I just want to plead with you not to judge me.

I ate a lot whilst in New York, and aside from a panic green side salad to go with a whopper of a plate of meatballs and spaghetti on the last day, I’m pretty sure not a single portion of my five a day was consumed on the entire week-long trip.

Waaaaaaait a second, maybe that’s why my jet lag feels extra heinous and I feel like a shriveled up shrimp sobbing into its dry pink skin.

Pink skin because hey I still have a burnt back from a few hours in the sun at Coney Island. But you can blame Chris for that one because he didn’t offer to rub sun cream into my back. The rascal.

So anyway, New York food porn. Oh man I’m hungry.

IMG_8692

1.BUVETTE

I had to mention this little French hun first because as soon as the food entered my mouth I just felt like everything in the world was at peace.

We went for brunch at Buvette and the menu has all the French classics like croissants and jam and that, but we ordered big – sharing the waffle sandwich with maple syrup, bacon and cheese, and the cheese, ham and egg toastie. Oh sweet jesus, I don’t think any words or photos will do it justice here. Just trust me when I say it is everything. Even the orange juice tasted like it’d been kissed by angels.

Oh and we spotted Liv Tyler in there. It’s located in Grove Street in Greenwich Village and just a quick head’s up, it gets pretty busy at weekends.

IMG_8670

2. THE MEATBALL SHOP

We actually ended up at this sweet carby heaven twice during our trip, mostly because we couldn’t be bothered to venture down to Italy from our Midtown hotel and fancied big homely bowls of pasta. I think there’s about five restaurants in NYC – one in Brooklyn, one on the Upper East Side and one in Greenwich Village, to name a few.

As the name suggests, they specialise in meatballs and you can choose from pork, beef, veggie or speciality ones, and then choose between different sauces and sides – things like spaghetti and salad and rigatoni.

Every portion comes with a hefty grating of Parmesan and portion of bread too because obvs.

Our fave was the night we visited the Chelsea branch and sat outside with a caraffe of red wine and soaked in the sweet, warm Memorial Day weekend vibes and chatter lingering in the air. Perfection.

IMG_8535

3. DOUGH

If you think Krispy Kreme doughnuts are peak deliciousness than oh mumma, you are in for one heck of an experience.

Americans just do doughnuts about 73756475 times better than us lame Brits, I’m telling ya.

This little joint is the perfect pit stop after a long day of walking (the main Manhattan Dough branch is only a few streets away from both Union Square and Madison Square Park). I ordered the coconut one and can confirm it was a thing of my filthiest dreams, although I’ve also heard super sexy things about the dulce de leche one. Ah man, can someone send me one right now plz?

IMG_8674 (1)

4. EMACK & BOLIO’S

I thought this was going to be some fancy, slightly-hipster ice cream joint, but nope. It was just plonked near Central Park and full of school children snapping up cones on their sweltering walk home from school, which is what I really liked about it.

Aside from having a giant list of ice cream flavours that involve a lot of caramel, chocolate chips and nuts, they also have the sexiest cereal cones known to man – held together with marshmallow for extra sassy flavourness.

I think these came in at about £8 each but when they hold as much Instagram glory as these huns and taste like diabetes, who even cares?

IMG_8902

5. EGG SHOP

This was one of those places we’d been heavily recommended and then mildly freaked out over the menu and the vibe and WHAT DO WE ORDER.

I always know when Chris is overwhelmed because he’ll just order the same as me and I’m like HOW WE BE DO SHARESIES IF WE HAVE THE SAME THING.

Anyway, I *think* the menu is kinda split into two – egg bowls and egg sandwiches. We opted for the bowls with avocado and pulled pork, topped with some crispy blue thing that tasted insane and added the dreamiest crunch texture. Although the girls next to us looked like they had avo on toast with egg, so that’s another reason to visit.

A good alternative to eating pancakes, and also because of all that protein and that it meant I didn’t crash into some sort of hideous sugar crash by 11am.

IMG_8705

6. SHAKE SHACK

This place is a no brainer, even though yeah alright we DO have it in the UK now or whatever. It’s not the same.

The Madison Square Park branch is the best because hey what’s better than eating cheeseburgers in the sunshine? And also, I think(?) it might be the first Shake Shack. Although expect to queue for about 20 minutes to place an order and then another 20 minutes for your food if you insist on going at peak lunch break time.

I just want you all to know that this is my number one burger of all time, so there’s that. UH HUH, above a McDonald’s double cheeseburger. I know, I feel like I’ve betrayed my one true love.

IMG_8421

7. DELICATESSEN

Chris and I were loitering around Macbar in Soho waiting for a table to become free so we could rest our poorly little feet and drown in macaroni cheese when we noticed this fellow next door.

It’s a restaurant with an open front and a lot of pavement seating, so it gives off a really chill holiday vibe because you just get to sit and watch the city go by around you. AND GUESS WHAT? Turns out they actually serve all the macaroni cheese dishes from Macbar, maybe they’re owned by the same person or something.

Anyway, this is another place we ended up twice because we just liked the vibe and sweet mother have mercy, the chicken wings. I don’t know what made them so good, but they had some Korean chilli sauce on them and they were out of this world. I think about those wings every hour, on the hour.

You can go for breakfast, lunch or dinner, and the cocktail menu is pretty handsome too. Both times we went we just ordered a couple of starters and sides to share, rather than go for the mains and they were immense. Standing ovation to the cheeseburger spring rolls, also.

IMG_8633

8. BAOHAUS

Admittedly, I wasn’t overwhelmed by the set-up of Baohaus in the slightest.  I just really wanted some Taiwanese steamed buns more than life itself and this was apparently the place to go.

It’s in a dark and dingy little shop in the East Village, and we were a bit like how do we order and what do we order and how much do we want and in the end we ended up with one bun each and some taro fries to share (taro being a root vegetable that I don’t hugely recommend).

There are seats to sit in, but they were all taken, so we found a little park to take our box of buns and fries to. And, despite the fact I didn’t like the restaurant or the fries, the pork belly bun was so good that I wanted to weep with happiness forevermore. And that’s the reason Baohaus made the list, that bloody sexy perfect pork belly bun.

So yeah, if you’re swinging by East Village and feeling peckish, you must buy one. I insist. Your future happiness depends on it.

IMG_8830

9. MELON JUICE

OK, this is a bit of a weird one. But basically, in New York, there’s a lot of street vendors selling like kebabs and pretzels and things and JUICE. All the fresh juice made on the spot for you.

Order the melon one. There’s always a melon one. It’s a combo of watermelon, honeydew and cantaloupe and ice and it is the most soothing and healing drink known to man.

Tired? Hungry? Headache? Hot? Sad? Hungover? This $5 badger will sort you out. And it tastes dreamboatin’.

So yeah, stop by a street vendor and snap one of these hunks up, you won’t regret it.

 

Have you eaten at any of these places, homegirls?

 

  • It was cruel to post this so close to lunch time, my tummy is a’rumbling right now!! Alice xx

    http://www.woodenwindowsills.co.uk

  • No, but I am suprised Tick Tock Diner didn’t make the list, mainly cos the last and only time (sob!) I’ve been to NY was about 10 years ago and I still think about their heavenly breakfasts. This list has definitely had me looking at flight prices though. Cant wait to hear about the rest of your trip 😊

  • Any holiday is always about the food for me!! I try to fit in as many meals as possible! This is a great list. I’ll have the chicken wings from Delicastessen and the coconut doughnut from Dough please! Thank you.
    Vicky xx
    http://www.dalton-banks.co.uk

  • All I can say is THANK GOD I was eating whilst reading this!!! x

  • Stacey

    Hi Hannah! Becky on beauty retweeted your post and I clicked on to read because I a) love NYC and b) love food so was a no brainer really. I loved this post so much! Literally book marked it for my next trip. The meatball place? Looks amazing. And a shop that sells all Mac and cheese is literally something I have probably dreamt about! If you go again you must try Norma’s for breakfast. It’s close to Central Park, 59th street I think. Their breakfasts were to die for.

    i live in Dubai and we actually have Shake Shack here-but I have never been!! I feel I need to rectify pronto!!

    Thanks so much for sharing this!

    Stacey xx

  • Omgggg those doughnuts look so tasty! Sophie x

    https://stylestarsandsparkle.blogspot.co.uk

  • All of these places look so amazing, I don’t really know where I’d start. Probably Meatball Shop. Because allways Italian and always carbs. xx

    http://www.girlglobalising.com

  • Amy

    Ugh seriously hungry now! Those ice creams look insane and I could definitely eat a burger right now even though I just ate lunch! Also don’t feel bad about eating loads – what else are holidays for?!
    Amy xx
    http://www.callmeamy.co.uk

  • Oh mumma this post made me hungry. The Meatball Shop is one of my fave places in New York too, I love how simple and delicious it is! Also its always fun to feel like you’re doing a questionnaire when you’re ordering your food, isn’t it?! x
    Sophie Cliff

  • bee

    Girlllllll, what are ya doing to meeee?! Anything that has a big, juicy burger on is enough to send my fat tum-tum in to overdrive!
    Bee | QueenBeady.com

  • Sam

    Dough and Emack & Bolio’s look AMAZING. xx

    Sam // What I Know Now

  • han

    Sweet jesus.

    Hannah | Oh January

  • These all sound bloody amazing. I don’t judge all the food you ate, the only reason I travel is to eat! 😀

  • loved this post so much, definitely have to check out some of those places if i’m in new york

    x Lilli
    please check out my fashionblog if you want: http://www.LilliFerreira.com

  • I am not going to NYC, I am on a diet and I am starving and now I also kind of hate you a teeny bit because I want to eat ALL OF THIS FOOD NOW xxxx

    The perks of being a hipster – Mykonos Part 1

  • Saving this post for my trip to New York in November!

  • Fi

    This post is most definitely being kept for future reference – namely my December New York trip. So THANK YOU! Although lord knows how I’ll fit this in, can I eat six meals a day I wonder…
    As for Shake Shack being the best burger ever, I’m so totally with you. I could eat it all day everyday. Yum! x

  • Your photos make me want to go to New York so much, just for the food! The ice cream cone is all I need right now.

    Rachael at broomfie.blogspot.com

  • As delicious as everything looks, I think out of them all I REALLY need to go to the Meatball shop. YUM!
    And I’ve never thought to have melon juice before, but it looks so refreshing 🙂

    http://www.justbeingbrooklyn.com

  • 100% saved this for my trip there. We were stuck for choice when we went last time, so I need organisation!! ALL of this food looks absolutely amazing. Definitely need to try Emack and Bolios though, seen it sooo many times on Lichipans instagram xx

    Tamz | http://www.throughneweyesx.com

  • YUM! Is it bad that I knew that first photo was Shake Shack before I even saw it listed out? Haha. Those donuts look heavenly too!

  • Shake Shack!! That’s an awesome place. The lines at all the locations are always ridiculous, especially in the summer, but it’s definitely worth it.

  • This post has convinced me that I NEED to go to New York City one day and eat everything. This post has made me so hungry now! Great post and lovely photos, hope you enjoyed New York xxx

  • The Odeon, Indochine, Kean’s, the Corner Bar, Flight 151, Penang, Bar Pitti….

  • See, I envy you Americans! It’s a lot harder to find food like that in Canada. :-/

    – Young Earner
    http://www.youngearner.com/

    • Duchesse

      Come to Montréal. every bit as fabulous food-wise and you won’t pay a 30% premium on your dollar.

  • OMG this post is just life! And it’s made me super hungry! Thanks for that. I’m hoping to visit New York within the next year or so and I’m always looking for inspirations for things to do when I do finally go whether that be tips for eating out or places to go and this is the perfect post, thank you so much for sharing this foodporn pictures I’m off to have my dinner now.

    Kirsty x
    http://klearlykirsty.blogspot.co.uk/

  • Oh my, this is food porn at its best. THAT WAFFLE SANDWICH. That’s what dream are made of. And Dough, just wow. Those doughnuts. I feel like I missed out on a lot of the tucked away places in NYC last time I was there. But all of these place pretty much made the list for when I visit next time.

    Kathryn xx

  • Love reading this Hannah, I’m a total foodie when it comes to holidays too! We went to New York last month and I get a where to eat guide too! There’s so much choice, I felt like there wasn’t enough time in the day to eat all the time haha.

  • hannah

    Those ice creams look bloody insane! Swooooon

    hannatalks

  • Oh Goodness!! I can almost see my waistline expanding… As a new New Yorker I will be having a look at these on my adventures around the city! Thanks x

    http://www.englishgirlinnewyork.org

  • OH MY GOD I NEED EVERYTHING NOW

  • Ooh I look forward to trying some of these on my NYC adventure later this month 🙂

  • I drank so much watermelon juice when I went to NYC – I love it and a combo sounds even better.

  • Oh my goodness this has made me SO hungry! Those ice cream cones look amazing!!!! x

    http://www.shayholly.co.uk

  • I’m so crazy hungry now! Thank you for sharing this!

    Anika | anikamay.co.uk


Recent Videos

Follow Me